Roofer Fails in Attempted Murder Conviction Appeal

A roofer found guilty of attempting to kill a colleague following a drinking session just days after they first met at work, has had an appeal against his conviction rejected, despite claiming he was acting in self-defence.

Thomas Telford, who was sentenced to nine-and-a-half years’ in prison after being convicted of the attempted murder of Callum Thomas, argued that the trial judge was wrong to rule that his claim of self-defence could not apply to the case.

Telford was found guilty in November 2017 following a trial at Livingston Crown Court. Charges against included, attempted murder, assault of a neighbour and disposal of a weapon.

The trial heard evidence that Telford and the complainer Thomas, who were both roofers, had first met in August 2016, when working on a site in Edinburgh city centre.

After finishing work on 12 August they went drinking, before going back to Thomas’ house. Thomas told the court that he had gone for a shower and that when he returned Telford was stabbing the wall with a kitchen knife. Thomas punched Telford, and Telford retaliated by stabbing him twice.

A neighbour, who heard the commotion, ran into the flat and tried to intervene, only to be pinned against a wall by Telford. Thomas reportedly tried to dive over a couch to escape to the kitchen area, but as he did so he was stabbed a further four times in the back.

Telford lodged a special defence of self-defence in respect of his attempted murder charge, but he did not give evidence.

The trial judge concluded that the claim of self-defence failed as a matter of law, as there was no imminent danger to Telford and he had a means of escape when he had used the knife.

Refusing the appeal, the appeal judges said they were “unable to fault” the trial judge’s decision.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here